Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 22

Thread: McAllister vs. Strand / Walnut vs. Dark Chili

  1. #1
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2018
    Posts
    21
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Quoted
    10 Post(s)

    McAllister vs. Strand / Walnut vs. Dark Chili

    Short version:
    McAllister vs. Strand? Why? + Dark Chili vs. Walnut? Why?

    Long version:
    I'll be ordering my next pair of Allen Edmonds in a few days and have decided to bring some brogueing into my life. I've admired the Strand and the McAllister for quite a while and just can't manage to decide which one I prefer. They're both beautiful. For those of you with experience with one or the other (or, ideally, both!), why did you choose the one you did? Are you happy with the decision? Which would you pick now and why?

    Also, I've long thought the most appropriate color for either one is walnut. However, if I'm honest, that was mostly based on pictures, and when I've seen them in person, they've been a lot lighter, duller, and more 'yellow' than I expected. I'm not sure if that's because of the way they've been cared for, and the polish/cream that has been applied to them, or if pictures are just consistently misleading. Lately, dark chili has caught my attention, since it has a lot more of that red tone I've started to like. It seems a very versatile color, too. Of the two, which would you choose for a McAllister or Strand and why?

    Thanks in advance!

  2. #2
    Varsity Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    723
    Mentioned
    43 Post(s)
    Quoted
    223 Post(s)
    I have owned both in walnut and have sold both. I find that walnut can be a tough color to wear unless you want to look trendy. Granted, I see a ton of guys wearing walnut shoes with navy pants every day, it just doesn’t appeal to me any more. I still have a pair of walnut loafers that I pair with light blue, light Grey, or khaki/tan. Also, AE’s walnut can differ in shade from yellow to orange. You would have to buy them from a brick and mortar to make sure that you are getting the color that you want. I would recommend the dark Chili. I have a pair of University in Dark Chili and love the color!

    As for Strand vs McAllister, I would vote Strand. No real reasoning why, I just like it better

  3. #3
    Super Moderator LesserBlackDog's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Posts
    5,342
    Mentioned
    417 Post(s)
    Quoted
    1992 Post(s)
    Really depends on what you will be wearing them for/with, and what other shoes you already own. A darker colored Strand or McAllister is going to be a staple shoe that you can wear with just about any conceivable jacket/trouser combo in a business wardrobe. Either shoe in walnut is going to be much more "peacocky" and better suited for the more casual end of business wear (lighter suits, light and louder jacket/trouser combos). If you already own several pairs of conservative business shoes, then sure, why not branch out a little bit.

    I have a pair of walnut AE x BB Strands and I like them, especially in summer, but 9 workdays out of 10 I am in darker shoes. I certainly wouldn't get a walnut shoe as my first or even second or third pair of business shoes. They are just too loud and not versatile enough.

    As far as Strand vs McAllister - IMO the difference is negligible and you can pick whichever you prefer.
    Ben

  4. #4
    Varsity Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Posts
    1,040
    Mentioned
    66 Post(s)
    Quoted
    310 Post(s)
    I wear a lot of dark grey pants, so wearing a walnut-colored shoes is just too loud for me. I had a pair but it's gone now.

    AE's bourbon color is the lightest I have that I can still wear a lot.

    I own dark chili and yes, the color is versatile.

    McAllister vs. Strand? Flip a coin.

  5. #5
    Super Moderator DocDave's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Location
    The Great White North
    Posts
    3,514
    Mentioned
    203 Post(s)
    Quoted
    1316 Post(s)
    Walnut coloured shoes with blue pants is all the rage right now. So much so that I find myself actively avoiding the combination.

    By far my favourite pair of shoes that I own are a pair of McAllister in Chili. Can't say why I like them so much. Might be the colour or the brogueing , or the versatility of the shoe for how I dress.

    That said, I own several pair of Strands and like them as well. Tough choice and comes down to personal preference I'd say.

  6. #6
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2018
    Posts
    21
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Quoted
    10 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by Loafer28 View Post
    I have owned both in walnut and have sold both. I find that walnut can be a tough color to wear unless you want to look trendy. Granted, I see a ton of guys wearing walnut shoes with navy pants every day, it just doesn’t appeal to me any more. I still have a pair of walnut loafers that I pair with light blue, light Grey, or khaki/tan. Also, AE’s walnut can differ in shade from yellow to orange. You would have to buy them from a brick and mortar to make sure that you are getting the color that you want. I would recommend the dark Chili. I have a pair of University in Dark Chili and love the color!

    As for Strand vs McAllister, I would vote Strand. No real reasoning why, I just like it better
    Thanks, that's helpful! Sadly, I don't currently live anywhere near a brick and mortar AE store, but I'll be moving close to one soon. Life will be better then haha.

  7. #7
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2018
    Posts
    21
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Quoted
    10 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by LesserBlackDog View Post
    Really depends on what you will be wearing them for/with, and what other shoes you already own. A darker colored Strand or McAllister is going to be a staple shoe that you can wear with just about any conceivable jacket/trouser combo in a business wardrobe. Either shoe in walnut is going to be much more "peacocky" and better suited for the more casual end of business wear (lighter suits, light and louder jacket/trouser combos). If you already own several pairs of conservative business shoes, then sure, why not branch out a little bit.

    I have a pair of walnut AE x BB Strands and I like them, especially in summer, but 9 workdays out of 10 I am in darker shoes. I certainly wouldn't get a walnut shoe as my first or even second or third pair of business shoes. They are just too loud and not versatile enough.

    As far as Strand vs McAllister - IMO the difference is negligible and you can pick whichever you prefer.
    I'm getting them pretty much just for enjoyment. I am set for both business and casual shoes and am just getting this particular shoe, because I've admired both the Strand and McAllister for a while. All that to say, the specific use case (business/pleasure) doesn't actually matter that much. Thanks for the feedback! It also seems that most people find the Strand and McAllister close enough that there's no wrong answer there, so it's good to have an extra opinion saying the same.

  8. #8
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2018
    Posts
    21
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Quoted
    10 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by 3piece View Post
    I wear a lot of dark grey pants, so wearing a walnut-colored shoes is just too loud for me. I had a pair but it's gone now.

    AE's bourbon color is the lightest I have that I can still wear a lot.

    I own dark chili and yes, the color is versatile.

    McAllister vs. Strand? Flip a coin.
    That makes sense. I probably wear a bit more blue (navy slacks or denim) than grey, which is part of what made walnut appealing. Thanks for the feedback! I may literally end up flipping a coin

  9. #9
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2018
    Posts
    21
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Quoted
    10 Post(s)
    Quote Originally Posted by DocDave View Post
    Walnut coloured shoes with blue pants is all the rage right now. So much so that I find myself actively avoiding the combination.

    By far my favourite pair of shoes that I own are a pair of McAllister in Chili. Can't say why I like them so much. Might be the colour or the brogueing , or the versatility of the shoe for how I dress.

    That said, I own several pair of Strands and like them as well. Tough choice and comes down to personal preference I'd say.
    Thanks! This is helpful. Do you find that the Chili color is still light enough to show off the brogueing/wingtips on the McAllister? I could just be wrong about this, but that's one of the concerns I've had about darker McAllisters (e.g. I don't understand the point of a black McAllister, since there just doesn't seem to be enough contrast). The flip side is that with walnut I might want to slightly darken the shoes, but I'm not a huge fan of the effect when darker polish gets stuck in the brogueing and disproportionately colors it. (At this point I feel a bit like Goldilocks shopping for shoes haha!)

  10. #10
    Varsity Member mebejoseph's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2017
    Location
    So Cal
    Posts
    1,108
    Mentioned
    54 Post(s)
    Quoted
    441 Post(s)
    I have McAllisters but not in either color you are looking for. I like them quite a bit and they are quite comfortable. I think the Strand is on the same last, so you should find the level of comfort about the same either way. I think I prefer the look of the McAllisters. Perhaps the wing tip makes it look sleeker than the cap toe?

    As far as color, a friend of mine has the Fifth Avenue in dark chilli and it is a beautiful color in person and shows off the semi-brogue quite well. I have a couple of pairs of full brogue wing tip shoes in walnut and I agree with others that it is a much more trendy color to wear when you want to stick out a bit. If that's what you want, go with the walnut. But if you want a versatile shoe in a beautiful color that not that many people have, go with dark chilli.
    Intentionally overdressed for almost every occasion.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •