Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

[FIT ?] Banana Republic Tailored Fit vs J.Crew Ludlow

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • iLLmAtiCiAn
    replied
    yeah, the ludlow is better material, half canvassed you can feel it, but the fit is off, for me the waist seems huge (36s); it almost balloons out

    there's no way I can wear a ludlow without tailoring but I can get by on the tailored fit without it (besides the sleeves)

    Leave a comment:


  • joseph
    replied
    Originally posted by IronRinn View Post
    A little late on this, but figured I would chime in:

    My biggest issue with the Ludlows are the shoulders. A 40R in BR Tailored fit fits me well. The shoulders measure 17" seam to seam, the waists usually pull slightly, and the chest fits well. Tailoring takes care of the waist. A 40R in Ludlow measures 18" seam to seam, and was generally bigger all around. I had to size down to a 38R, which measures 17.75" and they are still a bit wide but not noticeably so, due to the fairly structured shoulder. The chest is fine and the waist pulls slightly, as with the BRs (again, tailoring fixes this).
    thanks! helps a lot

    Leave a comment:


  • IronRinn
    replied
    A little late on this, but figured I would chime in:

    My biggest issue with the Ludlows are the shoulders. A 40R in BR Tailored fit fits me well. The shoulders measure 17" seam to seam, the waists usually pull slightly, and the chest fits well. Tailoring takes care of the waist. A 40R in Ludlow measures 18" seam to seam, and was generally bigger all around. I had to size down to a 38R, which measures 17.75" and they are still a bit wide but not noticeably so, due to the fairly structured shoulder. The chest is fine and the waist pulls slightly, as with the BRs (again, tailoring fixes this).

    Leave a comment:


  • joseph
    replied
    thanks for the response guys
    appreciate it tons

    Leave a comment:


  • LesserBlackDog
    replied
    I find BR tailored fit to be snugger off the rack, especially through the chest and shoulders. But I only own two BR jackets and one Ludlow jacket, so I'm not exactly working off a scientifically valid survey size.

    Leave a comment:


  • Idle_Hands
    replied
    Originally posted by SlyTim View Post
    I have a wool/cotton blend BR blazer in a 36R that fits me absolutely perfectly. I have an unstructured Ludlow jacket in size small and it has tiny shoulders and sides that would fit if I gained 50 pounds.

    Regardless, I can't buy suiting at J Crew.
    That's weird. I own a BR tailored fit in 36R and an unstructured Ludlow in S and both fit me quite well. I've had friends/acquaintances specifically compliment the fit of each of them, in fact. The BR one I had the sleeves shortened and the Ludlow didn't need any alterations (but I thrifted it and suspect the sleeves were shortened).

    Edit (after reading Onerany's reply): Maybe my thrifted Ludlow S also had the sides taken in? I'm 5'8", 155 lbs.
    Last edited by Idle_Hands; April 13, 2013, 09:29 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • onerany
    replied
    Originally posted by SlyTim View Post
    I have a wool/cotton blend BR blazer in a 36R that fits me absolutely perfectly. I have an unstructured Ludlow jacket in size small and it has tiny shoulders and sides that would fit if I gained 50 pounds.

    Regardless, I can't buy suiting at J Crew.
    I have a Ludlow blazer in 36r that fits almost perfectly off the rack, with only the sleeves shortened, as well as an unstructured Ludlow blazer in size small. The latter fits well in the shoulders, but as SlyTim said, the waist is somewhat wide. I had it taken in but the jacket still feels a little large. Never bought a jacket from BR, but I have tried on 36R tailored fit several times and they've always seemed to fit great. If I had to compare, would say that the shoulders on the Ludlow jackets (in 36r) fit ever so slightly wider than BR, but both are miles slimmer than anything at Macy's.

    Leave a comment:


  • SlyTim
    replied
    I have a wool/cotton blend BR blazer in a 36R that fits me absolutely perfectly. I have an unstructured Ludlow jacket in size small and it has tiny shoulders and sides that would fit if I gained 50 pounds.

    Regardless, I can't buy suiting at J Crew.

    Leave a comment:


  • MarkB
    replied
    Originally posted by Redford View Post
    I have a pretty normal drop, about 6" and I had to have the waist taken in on my 38R Thompson. 39" chest here. It was just enough that it bothered when it was untailored. Also almost everyone will need to have the sleeves tailored on the Thompson so you factor in the $70 or so for tailoring and I was out about $255. A Ludlow in 38S fits me without the need for tailoring. Not sure what you can get those for on a good sale.
    I'm not sure you can even get the Ludlow jacket for $255 on sale (unless you're an uncommon size and score one off eBay), which is what makes the Thompson so popular, at least IMO.

    Leave a comment:


  • MarkB
    replied
    I'm also a 42R in BR tailored fit blazers and I bought a 42 in the Thompson. I had to size up in the ludlow blazer that I tried on. I actually bought a cotton ludlow off of eBay for $16 and its a L. That said, I did have to have the waist brought in and the sleeves shortened on it. I will also say that while BR tailored blazers fit me perfectly, except for the sleeves, their suit jackets fit like crap. I'm not even sure if there is supposed to be a difference in cut, but I tried from 40-44 in three different suits and none of them fit right in the shoulders. Not really sure what's up with that, but it sucked because the suits are pretty nice IMO.

    Leave a comment:


  • Redford
    replied
    I have a pretty normal drop, about 6" and I had to have the waist taken in on my 38R Thompson. 39" chest here. It was just enough that it bothered when it was untailored. Also almost everyone will need to have the sleeves tailored on the Thompson so you factor in the $70 or so for tailoring and I was out about $255. A Ludlow in 38S fits me without the need for tailoring. Not sure what you can get those for on a good sale.

    Leave a comment:


  • frost
    replied
    I personally think the Thompson is an excellent suit for the money. I'm not sure what anyone else could want in terms of fit or material at that price point.

    That said, it's hard to know what you're looking for from the Ludlow line.

    Leave a comment:


  • joseph
    started a topic [FIT ?] Banana Republic Tailored Fit vs J.Crew Ludlow

    [FIT ?] Banana Republic Tailored Fit vs J.Crew Ludlow

    How do they compare? BR's tailored fit blazers fit me very well, but i haven't had much experience with the ludlow. I tried the thompson at a j.crew factory, but i was rather disappointed with the piece overall.

    normally i'm a 42r in a br tailored fit blazer.

    on a side note, a club monaco 42 (grant fit) also fits me very well.

    anyone else have any experience? the j.crews in san diego are alarmingly bad for menswear so i don't get much of an opportunity to test things out so i end up buying smaller things online.
Working...
X