WIWT

[LosRockets]

Pull, nice cold-weather outfit. I like the shape and fit on the suit. I suspect the pictures don't do full justice to the fabric and finish of the suit.

Sharp contrast with the shoes color, but I thinks it works well.

Full Windsor? I would like a slimmer knot.

Agreed, nice outfit but go w/ a four-in-hand knot.

[pull]

Pull, nice cold-weather outfit. I like the shape and fit on the suit. I suspect the pictures don't do full justice to the fabric and finish of the suit.

Sharp contrast with the shoes color, but I thinks it works well.

Full Windsor? I would like a slimmer knot.

Thanks for the feedback. It's called a Nicky knot. I did a Half Windsor first, but then this one. I find it difficult to get the dimple with the half windsor in a skinny tie, and I wanted a little heft with the semi-spread. I usually do go slimmer, though.

On the suit - you are exactly right. It's an outstanding suit in fabric, finish and color - I honestly can't believe it's BR, even if it is one of their upgraded collections. It's made from the same wool-cashmere that J. Crew uses, I think - Tollegno 1900.
Here's the kicker: list price was $650, but with sales and codes, I got the whole suit for ~$110 once it made it to clearance around christmas; a testament to lessons on this site.

[pull]

Agreed, nice outfit but go w/ a four-in-hand knot.

thanks - I rarely wear ties, so it's good to get feedback - I've tied any tie I've owned the same way since high school, i.e. one style of knot. So, I was trying something different and am looking fwd to trying these others.

[LosRockets]

ninpb - love that jacket! looks good!

[BB]

Lots of these WIWT pictures have sweaters in them. Why not submit to the Friday challenge?

[3piece]

Shoes: Allen Edmonds Strand
Bow tie: Carrot & Gibbs
Watch: Timex Dress Strap
Pocket Square: Macy's
Everything else MTM, local tailor

[aetucker1]

Shoes: AE Fifth Avenue Medallion Tip
Jacket: Alfani Slim Fit Velvet
Jeans: JC
Sweater: Apt9
Shirt: Michael Kors...i think.
Square: Original Penguin
Socks: no idea.
Tie: Apt9

[MarkB]

Tried leaving the shirt untucked today, not something I normally do. What do you guys think of this look?

The sweater actually fits quite trim, must have ridden up on me when I was playing with kids when I got home.
Jacket: Gap Outlet
Sweater: JC lambswool (picked this up two weekends ago for $20)
Shirt: Thomas Mason for JC (hard to beat for the $15 I paid)
Pants: Uniqlo
Shoes: Clark's
Watch: Timex

[dackman]

Tried leaving the shirt untucked today, not something I normally do. What do you guys think of this look?

The sweater actually fits quite trim, must have ridden up on me when I was playing with kids when I got home.
Jacket: Gap Outlet
Sweater: JC lambswool (picked this up two weekends ago for $20)
Shirt: Thomas Mason for JC (hard to beat for the $15 I paid)
Pants: Uniqlo
Shoes: Clark's
Watch: Timex

I like the outfit MarkB, and nice lighting improvement on your pics, much easier to see details.

I'd say if your at home with the kids, untuck, as I do as soon as I step in the door from work. Out in the world, definitely tuck it in, even on the casual outfit, just looks cleaner IMO.

[Duvel]

dackman, that's really interesting because that's exactly what I do. I actually have tried wearing my shirt untucked under a sweater with chino "out in the world," and I immediately felt awkward and sloppy. I love wearing it that way at home, though--it feels very relaxed. But out in public I feel like it makes me come across as just another guy who likes to look like a slob (and I don't).

However, if I'm wearing jeans, I will almost invariably leave my shirt untucked. Tucked with jeans (almost aways) seems wrong.

[MarkB]

This is why I posed the question originally. I almost exclusively tuck my shirt in, mainly because I feel that the tails of most of my shirts are too long. I've seen some people pull this look off and wanted to give it a whirl. I did feel kind of sloppy at first, but once I left the house I forgot about it. Sometimes I feel that the tucked in shirt under a crew neck sweater comes off a little stuffy, so I figured I'd try it this way.

[buffalobills12]

WIWT

First wiwt:returning for the spring semester in the polar vortex

Jacket:lands end oil cloth
Shirt: J Crew
Jeans:Gap Selvage
Scarf:Club Monaco
Bag: Bonobos/Frost River

Not pictured:Sorel Caribou boots
Skagen watch

[cjl1978]

Oilcloth

Nice look. If anyone wants one of these oilcloth coats in medium let me know. I never wear mine.

First wiwt:returning for the spring semester in the polar vortex

Jacket:lands end oil cloth
Shirt: J Crew
Jeans:Gap Selvage
Scarf:Club Monaco
Bag: Bonobos/Frost River

Not pictured:Sorel Caribou boots
Skagen watch

[Duvel]

Nice look. If anyone wants one of these oilcloth coats in medium let me know. I never wear mine.

Sure, I'll take it. Good looking coat.

[MarkB]

Sure, I'll take it. Good looking coat.

Beat me to the punch.