Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Advice on replacing a 20 year old work horse jacket

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Advice on replacing a 20 year old work horse jacket

    Way back when I was a sophomore in college (1999), I purchased a dark blue, Polo "Newsboy" work jacket. It had incredibly thin corduroy-like lines on it and was flannel lined and lightly filled. At the time, I had no idea to know what a mainstay it would be for me. It's been tailored maybe three times now over the 20 years. The last straw for me was that I have to replace the pockets, yet again (I don't keep anything in them but my hands!). I decided enough was enough. It's a great coat but I've run my course with my 'ole pal. Time to finally replace this faithful legend.

    I ask the group to pour forth their experience and wisdom to help guide me to my next 20 year coat.

    Here's what I can tell you about me:
    • I'm active and am always on the go. I get around mostly by walking or the bus. Occasionally bikeshare and sometime, although rarely, I drive. This means, I'm always out in the elements. I live in Oregon. It rains a lot, sometimes it's pretty windy and it's cold. Not freezing but damn close. I'm not asking for a rain coat. This coat comes out if I have an umbrella or it's the dead of winter and the rain is gone and only the frigid cold remains.
    • I like tailored fits. Not tight but closely cropped. It helps keep the wind out.
    • No parkas.
    • A classic, timeless look would be nice. Nothing too trendy or ready to go out of vogue next season (IE: Quilted. I've already got one anyway.)
    • I'm open to exterior materials. Heavy cotton or wool, even waxed could be possible so long as...
    • ... it's lined. This could be the single most important element. The Polo had a nicely filled, soft flannel lining. It was delightful to slip into. Never cold, always comfy. This one also must have the same kind of feel.
    • I don't want to say price isn't an issue but I'm patient and will wait for a deal, then strike. So for now, let's just say it's not an issue.


    Thus far, I've only found one example of a potential candidate. The Flint & Tinder Mill Jacket. Great looking work style coat but even after speaking with customer support, nobody could give me any information on the fill count, or thickness, of the liner inside. So, I've passed only because of that. It looks like it is a strong contender though.

    All that said, please provide your thoughts on what a suitable replacement would be. I'm all ears.

    #2
    Maybe shomething in the Carhartt line? They have all kinds of jackets.:

    https://www.carhartt.com/category/ca...SAAEgIVE_D_BwE

    Fritz

    Comment


      #3
      My thought was Filson or Carhart as well.

      Comment


        #4
        Since you're probably perusing Huckberry (Flint and Tinder is one of their main lines)...might take a look at the Roark Revival Axeman Jacket. The fill material may be a little more than you're looking for and it has a water resistant nylon shell so if you want to stick with a natural material (cotton, waxed or not, or wool) then I'd rule it out. It's similar to the F&T Mill Jacket in silhouette though. Another option might be Pendleton - they're mostly known for their sweaters but make some decent workwear inspired outerwear too. Also Patagonia has branched out some from pure technical stuff into making some casual jackets for everyday wear. Google their Maple Grove Canvass Jacket or their Iron Forge Hemp Canvass Ranch Jacket for a couple examples.
        “Clothes make the man. Naked people have little or no influence on society.” – Mark Twain

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by JBarwick View Post
          My thought was Filson or Carhart as well.
          Could add Woolrich to that list as well.

          Comment


            #6
            Whew! Now that's a list! Thanks to all that have contributed as you gave me quite a bit of research fodder for the evening.
            In the end, I've got two I'm looking at. The Patagonia Men's Iron Forge Canvas Ranch Jacket and surprisingly, the Pendleton Wolf Point Baseball Jacket. Both brands I did not consider before posting this.

            Any others, feel free to chime in as I'm still not 100% sold but I'm getting closer.

            Thanks, all!

            Comment


              #7
              Yes Woolrich is a good call too. I talked myself into the Roark Revival Axeman jacket (black with corduroy collar which was the only one on Huckberry - there are other configurations available on the Roark Revival site)...I don't have a weather resistant nylon-shell insulated jacket and they're pretty ideal for the DC area, where it doesn't get super frigid - generally through the winter we're hovering around freezing with either cold rain or (less frequently) heavy wet snow when it precipitates. I have a nylon shell down parka but I really only need that when I visit the folks in Michigan in the winter as it does not get cold enough to need it in the DC area except for the occasional polar vortex winter. Scheduled to arrive tomorrow so I'll let you know what I think of it.
              Last edited by mark4; September 19, 2019, 10:30 AM.
              “Clothes make the man. Naked people have little or no influence on society.” – Mark Twain

              Comment


                #8
                A couple suggestions:

                Lands End Barn Coat (Currently ~$90 with 40% F&F Code "Family" plus an additional 10% Cash Back if you're signed up for Rakuten... if not, sign up here: https://www.rakuten.com/r/EMILNA6?eeid=28187)
                https://www.landsend.com/products/me...59?sku_0=::3LA

                Lands End Essential Quilted Cotton Jacket (Currently ~$50 with 40% F&F Code "Family" plus an additional 10% Cash Back if you're signed up for Rakuten... if not, sign up here: https://www.rakuten.com/r/EMILNA6?eeid=28187)
                https://www.landsend.com/products/me...59?sku_0=::KHA

                This BR jacket looks like it's cotton lined in the body and it's a pretty classic Barbour style jacket that's not likely to out of style anytime soon
                https://bananarepublic.gap.com/brows...p-page-content

                LL Bean has some similar items that fit the bill as well:
                Warm Up Jacket Flannel Lined: https://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/1114...4714-GN2&csp=f
                Field Coat Cotton Lined: https://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/1821...4714-GN2&csp=f
                Lined Canvas Shirt Jacket: https://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/1232...4714-GN2&csp=f

                Faherty has some nice "blanket lined" stuff:

                https://fahertybrand.com/collections...fur-dyed-black
                https://fahertybrand.com/collections...-river-glade-1
                https://stagprovisions.com/collectio...di-jacket-fw19

                This Rogue Territory jacket is expensive, but nice!
                https://stagprovisions.com/collectio...ly-jacket-fw19

                Comment


                  #9
                  Since a work jacket seems acceptable to you, I love this Orvis coat. The flannel lining is really comfortable. I wear it down into the 30’s by itself and add a vest when it drops into the 20’s.
                  https://www.orvis.com/p/classic-barn-coat/8R5R

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by shockfinder View Post
                    Since a work jacket seems acceptable to you, I love this Orvis coat. The flannel lining is really comfortable. I wear it down into the 30’s by itself and add a vest when it drops into the 20’s.
                    https://www.orvis.com/p/classic-barn-coat/8R5R
                    Good call on Orvis!

                    They also have this Weatherbreaker which looks very similar to the original jacket:
                    https://www.orvis.com/p/weatherbreaker-jacket/1z5b

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by shockfinder View Post
                      Since a work jacket seems acceptable to you, I love this Orvis coat. The flannel lining is really comfortable. I wear it down into the 30’s by itself and add a vest when it drops into the 20’s.
                      https://www.orvis.com/p/classic-barn-coat/8R5R
                      That's the kind of review I want to hear. Someone who has it and uses it. Added the Orvis to the list above for three solid choices.

                      Anyone else out there?

                      Thanks to all that have posted and especially the effort by [MENTION=6476]emynd[/MENTION] for the in-depth linked list!

                      Comment


                        #12
                        I had one of those Orvis coats, and they don't have any sort of fill or insulation. Shockfinder must be impervious to cold, or else he uses it with many layers.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by the passenger View Post
                          I had one of those Orvis coats, and they don't have any sort of fill or insulation. Shockfinder must be impervious to cold, or else he uses it with many layers.
                          Shots fired!

                          "Classic red plaid lines the pockets and coat"

                          Well, technically, it doesn't say anything about fill or insulation. I'd like to hear more because I do like this coat but I do have two others I've whittled it down to in case the Orvis doesn't make the cut.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            I mean, there's nothing wrong with it for what it is, but I don't think you'll get the same use from it in cold weather that you did from your old coat. I take public transit, so I am outside waiting for buses and trains in the morning. For me it was fine when it was around the upper 40s when I was leaving the house, but if it was colder I would need either another layer or a warmer coat.

                            Technically, I still have it. It's in storage in my basement, very gently used. What size are you, and how do you feel about red? I'll make you a good deal.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              I have this...but not much lining.
                              https://huckberry.com/store/flint-an...trucker-jacket

                              If you really want it to last another 20 years, I would seek feedback from anyone that owns one of these:
                              https://www.filson.com/tin-cloth-sho...-fco-000000468

                              Or these:
                              https://www.filson.com/tin-cloth-jac...-fco-000000044


                              I bought my Trucker on sale, but wish I had saved up for the second Filson listed!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X