Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

When you wear a cardigan people say...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    When you wear a cardigan people say...

    To me that I look like Me Rogers, an American treasure no doubt, or someone's grandpa. At 37, I'm neither.

    Do people compliment them or ride you a little?

    Full disclosure:
    I give out a fair amount of good natured ribbing. I also happen to work in a school that is less casual than a Walmart.

    Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk

    #2
    Same. Mr. Rodgers. I think it’s one of the harder items to pull off. I usually have one in the office when it’s cold or under a jacket to minimize it being a focal point. I’m 33

    Comment


      #3
      I wear enough wierd stuff that a cardigan is the least of anyone worries.

      Comment


        #4
        I'm 36 and love cardigans. I'll get a little bit of jokes, but screw it. I love em. I don't have a ton of cardigans because I view these as my luxury items in that I want them to last for essentially ever, so I'm willing to spend a bit of money on them. I like the kind of chunky shawls one a lot. I had bought one from Bonobos a couple of years ago - was not cheap, but that thing did not hold up as I'd like it have given the cost. I still wear it but caused me to sour on Bonobos a bit.

        Last year, I bought a one from Polo Ralph Lauren. Grey shawl one. It was originally over $400, but I waited to late in the season (maybe late Jan), and ended up getting it for more than 50% off. Still a lot of money, but I think they are timeless, and I hope the quality allows it to last a long time. My one gripe is that I wish it was more of trimmer cut than it is. They also had a cool plaid one that started north of $500, but it never got down to a price where I could justify it.

        I've already started trying to find some this year that I can jump on late in the season at a substantial discount.

        Long live cardigans.

        Comment


          #5
          I'm 29, wear cardigans all the time. Receive untold amounts of what I would describe as good-natured ribbing in my workplace filled with military, law enforcement, and spook-types. Then again, I receive good-natured ribbing on much of what I wear, but cardigans probably receive the most. One coworker started calling me "Lord Cardigan," which I appreciated... Also receive comments about how cozy I look, which is too true.

          Comment


            #6
            It's unfortunate that it somehow got associated with old people, but it is what it is and the trick to pulling it off is to have an athletic build. You don't necessarily have to be ripped, just have well-built shoulders and a chest to fill it out.

            Also, this is an obvious answer but simply avoid wearing it the way it is portrayed being worn by old people in tv and films, which means avoid loose, chunky shawl cardigans in faded grays and browns.

            I'll be 40 in a few years, and I have a chunky black shawl cardigan and two fine-knit merinos in charcoal and dark brown as part of my staples. I also have fine-knits in burgundy, navy, and light gray that I'm planning to wear out as I'm aiming for a more minimal wardrobe.

            Comment


              #7
              I have a couple - one is a burly shawl collar one for the deep winter fireside and the others are lighter weight spring - early fall ones that are cotton or cotton linen blends. I usually wear the lighter weight ones over a t-shirt with jeans or chinos or shorts, and don't get many Mr. Rogers jokes, probably because I'm too dressed down. The burly one I mostly just wear at home. I've embraced the shirt-jacket/shacket as a cardigan substitute. Same convenience of a cardigan in that you don't have to pull it on and off over the head but a little more rugged. I don't get any Mr. Rogers jokes with those but depending on the shacket you might get some Paul Bunyan ones, so they add a little variety to the ribbing.
              “Clothes make the man. Naked people have little or no influence on society.” – Mark Twain

              Comment


                #8
                I avoid thin cardigans. Every time I try one on and look in the mirror, I think Mr. Rodgers. I have one chunky cotton Polo cardigan that my wife loves. Worn with jeans it comes off as comfy masculine, if there is such a thing.

                Comment


                  #9
                  I'm 40, and I'm wearing a cardigan today. A thick cotton job with a shawl collar. Walked my daughter to school, and back. Ran a few errands at lunch. Nobody said a word. Think about that...
                  instagram.com/cutandbasted
                  cutandbasted.tumblr.com

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by julius12 View Post
                    the trick to pulling it off is to have an athletic build. You don't necessarily have to be ripped, just have well-built shoulders and a chest to fill it out.
                    Very much this. I wear cardigans often, almost always shawl cardigans, and the more i cut down and work out, the less old Asian man I look (I'm only 31) when wearing them. Helps a lot to have decent traps.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Loafer28 View Post
                      I avoid thin cardigans. Every time I try one on and look in the mirror, I think Mr. Rodgers. I have one chunky cotton Polo cardigan that my wife loves. Worn with jeans it comes off as comfy masculine, if there is such a thing.
                      I think this is the real key. Chunky shawl works wonders, it pretty much does all the tricks of a sportcoat but less formally. Thin cardigan...not so much. Too bad it's so tough to find a good cheap basic navy/grey 100% wool shawl cardigan.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        I wear cardigans constantly, and I've only ever had compliments.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Here are some examples that show how a person's build can make or break the cardigan look.

                          The first 2 are fine knits, and the last 2 are chunky shawls worn with flat caps (another old man association). None of the guys are old, but notice how the guys with less than ideal bodies give off old men vibes.

                          https://i.pinimg.com/736x/52/c2/d0/5...tylish-man.jpg

                          vs.

                          https://i.pinimg.com/736x/27/56/87/2...-guy-style.jpg



                          https://i.pinimg.com/736x/ee/2d/e7/e...an-pattern.jpg

                          vs.

                          https://cdn.lookastic.com/looks/shaw...large-6041.jpg

                          Comment


                            #14
                            To the OP, I get a comment occasionally but I also get comments about wearing a tie or my shoes or my watches. The less tan positive comments are from dudes that we will kindly say have a look taht I do not wish to emulate. The positive comments come from women. I am fine with all of that scenario. And I even wear thin cardigans. I wear them like i used to wear casual hoodies though. Something liek this but with a slightly less stupid look on my face...usually



                            Originally posted by julius12 View Post
                            Here are some examples that show how a person's build can make or break the cardigan look.

                            The first 2 are fine knits, and the last 2 are chunky shawls worn with flat caps (another old man association). None of the guys are old, but notice how the guys with less than ideal bodies give off old men vibes.

                            https://i.pinimg.com/736x/52/c2/d0/5...tylish-man.jpg

                            vs.

                            https://i.pinimg.com/736x/27/56/87/2...-guy-style.jpg



                            https://i.pinimg.com/736x/ee/2d/e7/e...an-pattern.jpg

                            vs.

                            https://cdn.lookastic.com/looks/shaw...large-6041.jpg
                            are the first examples in your pairs supposed to be the "old man vibe"? I would counter that there is more going on that makes that vibe than a "less than ideal" body. I would also say that they all look decent to me.

                            But I think we can just go ahead and acknowledge that everything looks better on an athletic/"ideal" body.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Funny how cardigans remind people of Mr. Rogers when what he actually wore were some kind of zip-up round-necked sweater.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X