Cole Haan Air Colton and Air Madison sizing

[jordan]

Does anyone know if these fit true to size? I suspect the coltons may be going on sale soon in a color im watching. I've definitely got my eye on some Madison's too if they ever go on sale.

[jason_carreira]

I've got a pair of the Air Coltons and I think I went a half size down with them

[alan]

This goes to show how different people's feet can be. I couldn't fit into a Colton in size 12 to save my life, though every other shoe I own is a 12. Certainly size is important, but the shape is another critical component.

[CJJ]

I agree with Alan it depends on the shape of your foot. I picked up a pair of the Coltons in a 12. The fit is "snug" in terms of width but since they are leather I am sure they will give some. Other than that they fit well. All the other shoes in my closet are 12.

[frost]

I got the Colton in my usual size, but they still felt "tight" right under the tongue area. I returned them and got a pair of Allen Edmonds Strands instead.

[jason_carreira]

LOL It's some kind of rule in this forum that every discussion of shoes ends up with the AE Strands

[nicholascrawford]

Haha so true!

[frost]

Just doing my part. Broke them in today while working in downtown Manhattan. Got my first look at the Freedom Tower. Coming along quite nicely.


Still annoyed with the condition of my McTavish. They offered to take them back, but I feel like it's just a crap shoot with another pair. They may end up being worse than the ones I have..