Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

BR Monogram vs Jcrew Ludlow

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    BR Monogram vs Jcrew Ludlow

    Banana republic has 40% off no exclusions today. I've been considering this monogram wool/mohair: http://bananarepublic.gap.com/browse...&pid=932367002 or a J crew wool navy ludlow. 40% off drops this (with pants to make a full suit) to 388$ (plus I have 50$ in rewards) so that makes it substantially cheaper than Jcrew. Thoughts? Pics?

    Thanks!
    Chris

    #2
    I don't know much about BR Monogram, but if history has show, BR just slaps a name on something and charges more for it.

    Jcrew's Ludlow suit happens to be half-canvassed, so you ARE paying up for something tangible.

    Comment


      #3
      The site claims:

      Full lining adds structure and weight to drape smoothly. Underarm shields reduce the need for dry cleaning.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by Chris Mahanna View Post
        The site claims:

        Full lining adds structure and weight to drape smoothly. Underarm shields reduce the need for dry cleaning.
        ...all of their blazers have those. BR's PR dept. needs some serious help.

        Comment


          #5
          40% off at br should be their real msrp, tbh

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by fey View Post
            40% off at br should be their real msrp, tbh

            So in your opinion, wait and try and catch a ludlow on sale?

            Comment


              #7
              The Ludlow would be $450 and the BR would be $338 after his credit. All BR general opinions aside, it looks like the question is if the Ludlow is worth $110 more than the BR? Me being in the south and I not traveling much with a suit, I would probably go for the Ludlow if I could and save the BR credit for some chinos or something. The half lined jacket is probably a big advantage in my warm climate. So far my plan is that if I am spending less than the Ludlow I am going way under and trying something like a Claiborne, Stafford, Bar III or a Combatant Gentleman. I don't think the $110 is enough to sacrifice for...but $200+, yeah maybe.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by idvsego View Post
                The Ludlow would be $450 and the BR would be $338 after his credit. All BR general opinions aside, it looks like the question is if the Ludlow is worth $110 more than the BR? Me being in the south and I not traveling much with a suit, I would probably go for the Ludlow if I could and save the BR credit for some chinos or something. The half lined jacket is probably a big advantage in my warm climate. So far my plan is that if I am spending less than the Ludlow I am going way under and trying something like a Claiborne, Stafford, Bar III or a Combatant Gentleman. I don't think the $110 is enough to sacrifice for...but $200+, yeah maybe.
                Thanks for the opinion. I would consider the BR 388 either way (opportunity cost of the credit) so for a 70$ difference I'd definitely rather the Ludlow. My question now is, where did you find a Ludlow for 450? I've been stalking the sale section/promo codes, and can't seem to find any. I'm looking for a navy wool suit.

                Thanks!

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by Chris Mahanna View Post
                  So in your opinion, wait and try and catch a ludlow on sale?
                  Originally posted by idvsego View Post
                  The Ludlow would be $450 and the BR would be $338 after his credit. All BR general opinions aside, it looks like the question is if the Ludlow is worth $110 more than the BR? Me being in the south and I not traveling much with a suit, I would probably go for the Ludlow if I could and save the BR credit for some chinos or something. The half lined jacket is probably a big advantage in my warm climate. So far my plan is that if I am spending less than the Ludlow I am going way under and trying something like a Claiborne, Stafford, Bar III or a Combatant Gentleman. I don't think the $110 is enough to sacrifice for...but $200+, yeah maybe.
                  Yes, wait for the Ludlow. Like [MENTION=12021]idvsego[/MENTION] says, the $110 is not worth it. With BR Monogram, you're essentially getting a cheaply constructed suit with nice-ish fabric. Not worth more than $200 for me.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by Chris Mahanna View Post
                    Thanks for the opinion. I would consider the BR 388 either way (opportunity cost of the credit) so for a 70$ difference I'd definitely rather the Ludlow. My question now is, where did you find a Ludlow for 450? I've been stalking the sale section/promo codes, and can't seem to find any. I'm looking for a navy wool suit.

                    Thanks!
                    Last year J.Crew ran a promo of 30% off select suits. I think the standard navy wool suit was one of them, but with the jackets with double vents and pants in the slim fit option only.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by zxu426 View Post
                      Last year J.Crew ran a promo of 30% off select suits. I think the standard navy wool suit was one of them, but with the jackets with double vents and pants in the slim fit option only.
                      Well luckily, that's exactly what I want. I'll just cross my fingers and stay diligent.

                      Thanks everyone!

                      Comment


                        #12
                        I was pulling price from memory, I may have been off. Ludlow sales are getting tougher and tougher to find, sadly.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by Chris Mahanna View Post
                          So in your opinion, wait and try and catch a ludlow on sale?
                          Originally posted by bjmcgeever View Post
                          Yes, wait for the Ludlow. Like [MENTION=12021]idvsego[/MENTION] says, the $110 is not worth it. With BR Monogram, you're essentially getting a cheaply constructed suit with nice-ish fabric. Not worth more than $200 for me.
                          well said. don't get suckered into them because they are "on sale"

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X