Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Main site comments down?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #16
    Sadly there is no other solution but to pend comments or close them completely. IP banneds and registering to post are just speed bumps for the truly unruly trolls. There will always be a few who ruin it for the masses. There is no consequence on the internet.

    Comment


      #17
      Originally posted by akosmowski View Post
      [MENTION=2659]Deke[/MENTION] I like the new Bonobos design, and I rarely can say that. I found it nicely laid out AND user-friendly (OK, maybe friendly to just THIS user).
      Yeah, turns out it's just my work computer that doesn't like the website (and apparently Chrome for iOS). It was very slick when I got home and tried my personal one.

      Comment


        #18
        Originally posted by bruschetta View Post
        Dappered's comments section has been targeted by a high number of truly unpleasant people over the past few weeks. A group of people have been leaving highly offensive comments after every article. The comments include insults, personal attacks, and other overwhelmingly negative statements. This group of men paid special attention to the articles written by Beth and Amber.

        Dappered's staff can moderate this behavior to some degree, but it isn't a pleasant job. It's both disturbing and depressing to see this side of people.
        Yikes.

        Comment


          #19
          I was wondering what was going on. That is very sad. I too love the comments, and I hope they figure out a way to open them back up.

          Comment


            #20
            Originally posted by Shade View Post
            There is no consequence on the internet.
            For trolling alone, you're probably right, but if the comments get worse than that you can sometimes get them. I recently successfully identified the author of defamatory internet postings about a client of mine. It was expensive and time-intensive (but I repeat myself), but it can be done.

            Comment


              #21
              I wonder if it's possible to set commenting up like pre-screened security for the TSA. (Yes, I am using the TSA as a reference for good practices. We are all going straight to hell.)

              You know, separate commenters into two populations - pre-approved commenters who have a history of good conduct, whose comments will be published without oversight. And the general commenters, whose comments are flagged for moderation before being published. Ideally these classes of commenters could be manually manipulated, so a troll who posts a few nice comments to get pre-approved can be un-pre-approved if they start posting abusive comments.

              If this were feasible, it seems like it would cut down on the tedium of having to read and approve every single comment before it got published.

              My main concern is that the comments and the sense of interactive community are such an integral part of the Dappered.com experience that the website will suffer without them.
              Ben

              Comment


                #22
                Very unfortunate, but I understand Joe / the mod-squad's decision -- I've modded sites before and it is tiresome when you have to babysit everything. Particularly unfortunate that they decided to focus on Beth's and Amber's input, as I believe (and still do) that the Dappered community as a whole is rather appreciative of their efforts and also not sexist.

                Comment


                  #23
                  Perhaps requiring posters to use their real name would help. That, along with some more significant user validation requirements (email, phone, tying into Facebook, G+, etc).
                  Artofmanliness also does it pretty interestingly. You have to be approved to join, and in order to be approved you have to fill out a whole page of personal information.

                  Comment


                    #24
                    I would offer that this is could sort of be an expected failure of a drop-in system like Disqus that tries to facilitate having one account across a lot of communities.

                    A dappered-only discussion framework would make it more difficult for a couple sociopaths to either discover dappered on their own or follow a user here from some other community.

                    Comment


                      #25
                      Originally posted by LesserBlackDog View Post
                      You know, separate commenters into two populations - pre-approved commenters who have a history of good conduct, whose comments will be published without oversight. And the general commenters, whose comments are flagged for moderation before being published. Ideally these classes of commenters could be manually manipulated, so a troll who posts a few nice comments to get pre-approved can be un-pre-approved if they start posting abusive comments.
                      Originally posted by P J View Post
                      That, along with some more significant user validation requirements (email, phone, tying into Facebook, G+, etc).
                      Artofmanliness also does it pretty interestingly. You have to be approved to join, and in order to be approved you have to fill out a whole page of personal information.
                      Originally posted by theYeti View Post
                      A dappered-only discussion framework would make it more difficult for a couple sociopaths to either discover dappered on their own or follow a user here from some other community.
                      I think a combination of these ideas could potentially be the solution.

                      Mods, can you shed some light on whether you intend to re-open the comments in the near future?
                      My measurements, for context--> Body Type: Slim/Skinny |​ Weight: 175 lbs | Height: 6'1" | Neck: 16” | Chest: 40” | Waist: 33.5” | Shoulder: 18.75” | Sleeve: 35.5” | Bicep: 12.75” | Wrist: 6.75”

                      Comment


                        #26
                        Speaking as a forum mod only, I can say that we forum mods do not have any authority or control over the main site, including the comments section.
                        Ben

                        Comment


                          #27
                          Originally posted by LesserBlackDog View Post
                          I wonder if it's possible to set commenting up like pre-screened security for the TSA. (Yes, I am using the TSA as a reference for good practices. We are all going straight to hell.)

                          You know, separate commenters into two populations - pre-approved commenters who have a history of good conduct, whose comments will be published without oversight. And the general commenters, whose comments are flagged for moderation before being published. Ideally these classes of commenters could be manually manipulated, so a troll who posts a few nice comments to get pre-approved can be un-pre-approved if they start posting abusive comments.

                          If this were feasible, it seems like it would cut down on the tedium of having to read and approve every single comment before it got published.

                          My main concern is that the comments and the sense of interactive community are such an integral part of the Dappered.com experience that the website will suffer without them.
                          This is what FB and Google were thinking of when they wanted to enforce a real name policy for their respective social networks. The (uninformed?) backlash put an end to that!

                          Comment


                            #28
                            Whoa, I really hope my 'douchy scarf' comment wasn't taken as one of these unpleasant comments!

                            Originally posted by bruschetta View Post
                            Dappered's comments section has been targeted by a high number of truly unpleasant people over the past few weeks. A group of people have been leaving highly offensive comments after every article. The comments include insults, personal attacks, and other overwhelmingly negative statements. This group of men paid special attention to the articles written by Beth and Amber.

                            Dappered's staff can moderate this behavior to some degree, but it isn't a pleasant job. It's both disturbing and depressing to see this side of people.

                            Comment


                              #29
                              I haven't actively read the site in a few months, so I'm not saying there wasn't some sort of malicious attack...

                              ...but, I experienced an extremely intolerant/excessive level of moderation when I was regularly reading/commenting on the blog. I posted a comment to the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale article in which I misstated the price of Park Aves in 2012 and suggested that a the article could or should have mentioned another deal that was available at the time. Rather than rebutting or just deleting the comment, Joe permanently banned me for this reason, which I confirmed with him via email.

                              My point is that it seems to me like he/they were trying to control the tone of comments to an excessive degree and probably decided it is just easier to not allow comments at all.

                              Comment


                                #30
                                Not a regular poster here, but I frequent the comments section quite a bit. I really appreciate the comments, especially regarding fit and such, and also alternative deals if you can't afford the $1500 watch or Allen Edmonds that are posted in every article

                                I understand that you have to keep the negative nancies out, but it would be great if you could switch to another format that required a confirmed email address to sign up or something, as that might help to keep down on trolls. Other forums I frequent require a forum login to post comments on articles.

                                Anyways, getting rid of comments and making the articles "read only" is going to prevent a lot of people from continuing to follow the site, perhaps myself included.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X