For anyone in the market for some walnutty monk straps in 12D, I've already bought from this guy and he's an upright ebay citizen:
For less than the price of DSW house brand monk straps, you could have some English-made shoes that appear to be rebranded Alfred Sargents. It's the same brand (Poulsen, Skone, & Co) as the wingtips I just received from the same seller, and I love mine.
There's also another pair available in black, though I expect they'll get less attention in this forum.