I hope there isn't another JCP thread already. I searched and couldn't find one. So what do you guys think?
I took a few minutes today to go the dreaded shopping mall and check things out for myself. I have to admit, I am impressed. I tried on a tattersall button-down collar shirt that fit spot on, using my J. Crew shirt fit as the criterion. I wear a medium in J. Crew, mostly, and this was just about like a J. Crew medium. Size and fit... I felt like I was wearing a J. Crew button-down shirt.
I wasn't quite as sold on the material. It almost felt a little plastic-y. But maybe that's because I'm used to the J. Crew "secret wash" broken-in feel? Maybe this shirt would soften up over a lot of laundering? I checked the label--100 percent cotton.
And the prices can't be beat. $25 for a good-fitting button-down collar shirt.
I wasn't as impressed with some other things. I tried on a thin cardigan that I just couldn't get to fit well over the shirt. It was a little clingy and the proportions felt off.
The sweatshirts were pretty cool in the color scheme department, but the material, like the shirt, looked and felt plastic-y, a little synthetic.
I ended up indecisive about the shirt. But I'm feeling inclined to go back and grab it later this week on a longish lunch break from the office.


Reply With Quote
